Accident Lawyers – The Fernandez Law Group https://thefernandezlawgroup.com Tampa Injury Lawyers and Attorneys at Law Thu, 05 Mar 2026 19:37:04 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.1 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/favicon.png Accident Lawyers – The Fernandez Law Group https://thefernandezlawgroup.com 32 32 MAJOR LIABILITY REFORMS CHANGE AUTO ACCIDENT CASES https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2026/03/05/liability-reforms-change-auto-accident-cases/ Thu, 05 Mar 2026 19:37:04 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34872 Major Liability Reforms Change Auto Accident Cases - FREE Consultations, 813-489-3222

The post MAJOR LIABILITY REFORMS CHANGE AUTO ACCIDENT CASES appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
MAJOR LIABILITY REFORMS CHANGE AUTO ACCIDENT CASES
These changes can decide whether a case has value or is dead on arrival.
Florida car‑crash cases do not look the way they did a few years ago. Major liability reforms have transformed the state from a “something is better than nothing” system into one where a narrow finding about fault can completely wipe out an otherwise legitimate injury claim.
A recent motor‑vehicle trial underscored this reality when the defense obtained a full win by relying on the new rules, leaving the injured plaintiff with no recovery at all.
The heart of this change to liability reforms is Florida’s move to a modified comparative negligence standard in most negligence cases, including many auto accidents.
Under the new framework:
  • There is now a hard fault cutoff: If an injured person is found to be 51 percent or more responsible for what happened, they recover nothing, even if their medical bills and losses are substantial.
  • Fault still reduces damages below that threshold: At 50 percent fault or less, the plaintiff can still collect, but the award is reduced in proportion to their percentage of blame.
  • Small shifts in fault have outsized consequences: Moving from 49 percent to 51 percent fault does not just trim damages—it turns a potentially significant case into a complete bar to recovery.
Insurers and defense firms have adapted quickly to this environment, and their strategies reflect the new leverage the statute gives them.
Common themes with the changes to liability reforms include:
  • Building a majority‑fault narrative around the plaintiff: Expect heavier emphasis on speeding, distraction, tailgating, late lane changes, and other driver behaviors that can be used to argue the injured person was primarily to blame.
  • Greater use of technical evidence: Event data recorders, video footage, and detailed accident reconstruction are being pushed hard to persuade adjusters and juries that the plaintiff’s choices outweighed any negligence by the defendant.
  • Risk‑framed settlement offers: Carriers may present low offers with the argument that a jury could easily land just over the 50‑percent line, turning a “discounted” claim into a total loss for the injured party.
At the same time, HB 837 and related changes have shortened the time window to file many negligence lawsuits and tightened how medical charges are presented in court, limiting which billed and paid figures juries can see.
In combination, these rules mean that a Tampa Bay crash victim who delays seeking legal help, fails to document the scene, or casually accepts a high percentage of blame in early conversations may find the law stacked against them when it is time to negotiate or go to trial.
For questions or concerns about how major liability reforms change auto accident cases or any other legal matter, we offer a free consultation and detailed case evaluation.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about the new Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling, or any other legal matter, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com

MAJOR LIABILITY REFORMS CHANGE AUTO ACCIDENT CASES – 3/5/26

 

The post MAJOR LIABILITY REFORMS CHANGE AUTO ACCIDENT CASES appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
KNOW YOUR RIGHTS DURING A FLORIDA TRAFFIC STOP https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2026/02/05/rights-during-a-florida-traffic-stop/ Thu, 05 Feb 2026 17:27:34 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34762 New Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling and Crackdowns around Tampa Bay - FREE Consultations, 813-489-3222

The post KNOW YOUR RIGHTS DURING A FLORIDA TRAFFIC STOP appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
KNOW YOUR RIGHTS DURING A FLORIDA TRAFFIC STOP

In early 2026, traffic enforcement in the Tampa Bay area has been especially visible with DUI patrols, tougher fleeing‑and‑eluding consequences, and serious crash cases all in the headlines.

 

If you drive in Florida like most of our clients around Hillsborough or Pinellas County do, it is important to understand how a Florida traffic stop works, what officers can and cannot do, and what is at stake as a simple stop can easily turn into a DUI or felony investigation.
 

Gasparilla 2026: A Snapshot of DUI Enforcement in Tampa
 

Gasparilla is one of the biggest events of the year in Tampa, and it is also one of the most heavily policed weekends on local roads.
  • Local coverage of the 2026 parade shows that a relatively small number of people were arrested, but the vast majority of those arrests were for suspected drunk driving after the festivities wrapped up.
  • Tampa Police and other agencies placed extra officers along the main routes out of downtown and nearby neighborhoods to watch for impairment, speeding, and other dangerous behavior as crowds dispersed.
  • Law enforcement has publicly described Gasparilla as a major DUI‑enforcement weekend, not just a one‑off operation, signaling to Hillsborough County drivers that patrols will be out in force during large gatherings.

Know your rights during a Florida traffic stopCommon Reasons Drivers Get Stopped in Hillsborough and Pinellas

Most traffic encounters in Tampa Bay begin with something ordinary: a claimed moving violation or suspicion that a crime might be occurring.

  • Officers regularly cite issues like speeding, drifting in a lane, failure to signal, rolling through stop signs, or driving with broken or missing lights as reasons to initiate a stop.
  • In many DUI and criminal‑traffic cases in Hillsborough and Pinellas, reports mention “weaving,” inconsistent speeds, or late reactions to traffic signals as supposed signs of impairment.
  • Once the car is stopped, the officer may broaden the encounter into a DUI or criminal investigation based on what they claim to observe—such as the driver’s appearance, speech, or behavior.

Your Core Rights During a Florida Traffic Stop

Even during a stressful stop, Florida drivers still have important rights. Knowing the basics can help you avoid making the situation worse.

  • You generally must provide your driver’s license, registration, and proof of insurance if an officer lawfully requests them.
  • You do not have to answer questions about drinking, drug use, or where you have been and where you are going; choosing to remain silent about these topics is allowed and can keep you from saying something that will later be used against you.
  • Officers may ask you to step out of the vehicle, and in a suspected DUI case they may request that you perform roadside coordination exercises, which they will later describe in detail in their reports.
  • Once you are formally placed under arrest and officers begin custodial questioning about the alleged crime, you should be advised of your right to remain silent and your right to consult a lawyer.

There are very short deadlines—often ten days—to act if you want to contest an administrative driver’s license suspension after a DUI arrest in Hillsborough or Pinellas County.


Know your rights during a Florida traffic stop as a simple stop can easily become a DUIWhen a Stop Becomes a DUI Case in Tampa Bay

Once a Florida traffic stop turns into a DUI investigation, the potential consequences change dramatically, especially with the way Florida law treats repeat offenses and aggravating factors.

First DUI – Misdemeanor

A first DUI in Florida is prosecuted as a misdemeanor. Fines generally run from $500 to $1,000, with a maximum jail sentence of up to 6 months and a driver’s license revocation between 180 days and 1 year. If the driver’s breath or blood alcohol level is 0.15 or higher, or a minor is in the vehicle, the potential fine can increase up to $2,000, and the maximum jail time can rise to 9 months, along with mandatory ignition interlock and other conditions.

Second DUI within 5 years – Misdemeanor with enhanced penalties

A second DUI is still a misdemeanor, but if it occurs within 5 years of a prior conviction, Florida law builds in stricter consequences. There is a mandatory minimum jail term of 10 days, with a possible total of up to 9–12 months in jail depending on alcohol level and other factors. Fines typically start at $1,000 and can reach $2,000 or more when the BAC is 0.15 or higher or a minor is present, and the driver faces a 5‑year revocation of driving privileges, vehicle impoundment, and an ignition‑interlock requirement.

Third DUI within 10 years – Third‑degree felony

A third DUI where any prior DUI is within the last 10 years can be filed as a third‑degree felony. In that scenario, the court can impose up to 5 years in state prison, a fine of up to $5,000, and a 10‑year driver’s license revocation. Prosecutors retain some discretion and can charge certain third DUIs as misdemeanors, but when the 10‑year look‑back applies and a felony is pursued, the case is treated as a serious offense with long‑term licensing and sentencing consequences.

DUI with property damage – First‑degree misdemeanor

When an impaired driver causes damage to someone else’s property, the offense is elevated to a first‑degree misdemeanor, carrying up to 1 year in jail and fines generally between $500 and $1,000, along with possible probation, community service, and a license suspension.

DUI causing serious bodily injury – Third‑degree felony

If a DUI crash results in serious bodily injury to another person, the charge becomes a third‑degree felony, punishable by up to 5 years in prison plus fines and long‑term license consequences.

DUI manslaughter – Second‑degree (or higher) felony

When an impaired driver causes a death, the crime is typically charged as DUI manslaughter, a second‑degree felony with a maximum 15‑year prison sentence and the potential for permanent or long‑term license revocation; penalties can increase further if the driver leaves the scene of the crash.


Fleeing and Eluding: Why Not Stopping Can Be Worse Than the Ticket

Another trend affecting Tampa Bay drivers is Florida’s tougher stance on fleeing and eluding, which can turn a poor decision during a stop into a serious felony.

  • Florida Statute 316.1935 spells out a series of fleeing‑and‑eluding offenses, making it illegal to knowingly fail to pull over or to drive away from an officer who is signaling you to stop.
  • Basic fleeing can already be charged as a felony, and the penalties increase when prosecutors allege high speed, reckless driving, or that the officer’s lights and sirens were activated.
  • Recent updates raised the ranking of certain fleeing offenses on the state’s sentencing scale, which means those charges now carry heavier weight at sentencing and can more easily lead to prison time rather than probation.
  • When fleeing is connected to a crash that seriously injures or kills someone, the law requires mandatory incarceration, and the maximum penalties are similar to other high‑level felonies.

Know your rights during a Florida traffic stopFLORIDA Traffic Stops, Crashes, and Personal Injury Claims

Florida traffic stops that involve collisions often create both criminal‑law and civil‑law issues, particularly in heavily traveled areas like Tampa, Brandon, Clearwater, and St. Petersburg.

  • If a driver is accused of DUI or reckless driving and an accident occurs, prosecutors may file criminal charges at the same time that injured people—or the families of those who may have died—pursue separate claims for compensation.
  • Civil claims can seek recovery for medical treatment, lost income, future care needs, pain and suffering, and other long‑term effects of serious injuries.
  • In fatal crashes, surviving family members often bring wrongful death suits , using evidence from the original traffic stop, crash reports, and any chemical testing to try to establish liability.
  • Because criminal cases and personal injury cases use different burdens of proof, the outcome in one court does not automatically control what happens in the other.

What Drivers in Hillsborough and Pinellas Should Remember

If you are driving in Tampa Bay and you are worried about what could happen in a Florida traffic stop, a few core points are worth keeping in mind.

  • During large events like Gasparilla and holiday weekends, there is a strong chance you will see increased patrols and DUI enforcement on major roads and bridges in Hillsborough and Pinellas County.
  • Ordinary traffic issues can be enough to justify a stop, and what you say and do once you are pulled over can influence whether the situation stays minor or escalatesinto a criminal investigation.
  • DUI penalties in Florida ramp up quickly with each conviction, and factors like high breath‑alcohol readings, minors in the vehicle, crashes, or injuries can move a case into felony territory.
  • Choosing not to stop, driving away from a marked patrol vehicle, or speeding up after lights and sirens are activated can lead to separate fleeing‑and‑eluding charges that carry their own felony risks.
  • When injuries or fatalities are involved, there may be both criminal exposure and civil liability, and each system has its own deadlines and procedures that can significantly affect the outcome.

How our DUI and Traffic Violation Defense Lawyers Can Help:

After a Florida traffic stop in areas such as Hillsborough or Pinellas—whether it was a DUI arrest, a ticket that seems unfair, or a crash that caused injuries—it can be hard to understand your legal position just by reading articles online.

Speaking with a team of lawyers who regularly handle traffic violations, DUI defense, criminal defense, and personal injury matters in the Tampa Bay area can help you sort through potential defenses, protect your license, and evaluate any injury or insurance claims that may arise from the same incident.

For questions or concerns about your rights during a Florida traffic stop or any other legal matter, we offer a free consultation and detailed case evaluation.


EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about the new Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling, or any other legal matter, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com

KNOW YOUR RIGHTS DURING A FLORIDA TRAFFIC STOP – 2/5/26

The post KNOW YOUR RIGHTS DURING A FLORIDA TRAFFIC STOP appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
NEW FLORIDA SUPREME COURT DUI RULING https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2026/01/22/florida-supreme-court-dui-ruling/ Thu, 22 Jan 2026 20:23:38 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34725 New Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling and Crackdowns around Tampa Bay - FREE Consultations, 813-489-3222

The post NEW FLORIDA SUPREME COURT DUI RULING appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
NEW FLORIDA SUPREME COURT DUI RULING AND CRACKDOWNS AROUND TAMPA BAY

Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling: State v. Repple – Breath Tests Follow the Arrest, Not City Lines

On December 30, 2025, the Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling on State v. Repple was decided, closing a defense avenue that once allowed some drivers to suppress breath-test results when city officers crossed jurisdictional lines.

In Repple, a Maitland officer arrested a driver for DUI within city limits but transported him to a county facility outside the city for a breath test; lower courts initially excluded the results on jurisdiction grounds, but the Supreme Court reversed.

  • The Court held that under Florida’s implied consent law, a municipal officer who makes a lawful DUI arrest within the officer’s jurisdiction may request and obtain a breath test outside that jurisdiction as part of completing the statutory process.
  • The Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling emphasized that implied consent “attaches to the arrest” and that the officer’s authority to request testing is not cut off simply by driving across an “invisible line” into county territory to reach a breath-testing facility.
  • Before Repple, some trial and appellate courts had accepted arguments that extraterritorial testing by city officers was unauthorized “color of office” conduct; after the Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling in Repple, that strategy is significantly weakened, shifting the defense focus back to the legality of the initial stop and arrest.



For Tampa Bay area drivers, this means a DUI arrest initiated by a city officer—whether in Tampa, St. Pete, or another municipality—will almost certainly support valid breath testing at a central county facility, and suppression motions based purely on where the device is located are far less likely to succeed.

The Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling implies that the geography of where the machine sits matters much less than whether the officer had lawful grounds to stop and arrest in the first place.

The impact of this new Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling is significant and should be considered a warning to all Florida drivers.


Tampa’s DUI Crackdown: Checkpoints, Grants, and Holiday Sweeps
Tampa Bay Area DUI Enforcement Wave

Tampa Bay is now one of the most aggressively policed DUI corridors in Florida, with Hillsborough County consistently logging over 4,000 DUI arrests a year, outpacing even larger counties like Miami-Dade.

Recent DUI enforcement campaigns show a clear pattern of multi-agency operations, saturation patrols, and a “zero tolerance” message from local law enforcement leadership.

  • In a New Year’s Eve 2025 operation, HCSO and Tampa Police ran a joint DUI enforcement detail that produced 21 DUI arrests from 136 traffic stops, along with 17 citations and 105 warnings in a single night.
  • Earlier 2025 campaigns (including the “Lucky to Be Safe” St. Patrick’s weekend push) saw 142 stops and 33 DUI arrests, which clearly illustrates how Tampa’s enforcement rate rivals or exceeds much larger metro areas.
  • A $360,000 FDOT grant to HCSO is funding more DUI checkpoints, roving patrols, and technology to detect impaired drivers has helped reinforce Sheriff Chad Chronister’s warning that impaired driving “will not be tolerated.”

Tampa Bay area drivers need to be cautious and expect more late-night stops near downtown Tampa, Ybor City, South Howard, the beaches, and around major events including Bucs, Lightning and Rays games.

In many situations, our Tampa Bay area DUI lawyers are seeing situations where “borderline” behavior—rolling through a stop, drifting lanes, or minor equipment issues—can now turn into a full impairment investigation, especially during holidays and weekends flagged as high-risk periods.

The Tampa Bay Area DUI Enforcement Wave can have serious consequences

The Tampa Bay area DUI Enforcement Wave can have serious consequencesFor drivers, the practical risk isn’t just the number of patrol cars – it’s the cumulative impact of strict state penalties plus aggressive local enforcement.

  • A first-time Tampa DUI under Florida Statute 316.193 can bring $500–$1,000 in fines, 6–12 months’ license suspension, probation, DUI school, community service, and up to 6 months in jail, with enhanced penalties if the BAC is 0.15 or higher or a minor is in the car.
  • Tampa’s enforcement strategies which include mobile breath-test units, coordinated checkpoints, and data-driven patrols suggest DUI penalties are being sought after more often, as opposed to staying somewhat reserved for more extreme cases.
  • If a driver does not act within 10 days of arrest, a license suspension typically kicks in regardless of how the criminal case is resolved later.

More drivers are being stopped, more are being tested, and more are entering a system that now stacks even tougher court penalties on top of fast-moving administrative suspensions.


Tampa’s intensified DUI enforcement and the Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling in Repple create a situation where more drivers are stopped, more are tested, and fewer breath results can be excluded on technical jurisdiction arguments.

  • Saturation patrols, FDOT-funded checkpoints, and coordinated holiday operations make it more likely that even “I only had a couple” drivers will encounter a DUI investigation somewhere in Tampa Bay.


  • Once a lawful arrest is made, Repple makes it much harder to argue that breath results are invalid just because a city officer drove the suspect to a county testing site outside municipal boundaries.


  • Combined with Florida’s tough statutory penalties, the new Florida Supreme Court DUI Ruling, and tight DMV deadlines, the risk for anyone driving after drinking, even modestly, has never been higher in Hillsborough, Pinellas, and surrounding counties.

You may have questions such as whether you will lose your license and for how long? How much can you expect to pay in court costs and fines? Does your state offer a special “hardship permit” allowing you to drive to and from work? Is hiring an attorney really necessary? Would you receive the same outcome with and without an attorney?

Our Tampa DUI Defense attorneys are known for providing an unbiased solution to many of your questions. We offer a free step by step consultation on how to proceed based on your individual circumstances.

For questions or concerns about the new Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling, the increased DUI enforcement around Tampa Bay, or any other legal matter, we offer a free consultation and detailed case evaluation.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about the new Florida Supreme Court DUI ruling, or any other legal matter, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/tampa-personal-injury-lawyers/

NEW FLORIDA SUPREME COURT DUI RULING AND CRACKDOWNS AROUND TAMPA BAY – 1/22/26

The post NEW FLORIDA SUPREME COURT DUI RULING appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
ACCIDENT AND INJURY CLAIMS ARE EVOLVING IN TAMPA https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2026/01/08/accident-and-injury-claims/ Thu, 08 Jan 2026 20:18:47 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34720 Accident and Injury Claims are evolving in Tampa. Whether injured or managing risk, preparation & transparency are essential - FREE Consultations, 813-489-3222

The post ACCIDENT AND INJURY CLAIMS ARE EVOLVING IN TAMPA appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
ACCIDENT AND INJURY CLAIMS ARE EVOLVING IN TAMPA

Personal injury and auto accident cases in the Tampa Bay Area are increasingly decided by data, documentation, and timing.  Crash evidence presented in accident and injury claims now often includes vehicle telematics, dash and fleet camera footage, medical records, and digital communications — all of which insurance companies analyze early and aggressively.
 

In Tampa, St. Petersburg, Clearwater and surrounding communities, vehicle data often plays a decisive role in determining fault.  Speed, braking, and video evidence can quickly establish liability or protect responsible drivers when a crash was unavoidable.  Preserving this evidence early is critical, as key data can be lost if action is delayed.

Medical accident and injury claims are also under closer scrutiny. Insurers now routinely challenge medical billing practices, treatment necessity, and future care projections. Courts across Florida are placing greater weight on reasonable medical costs and clear documentation, not just billed charges.
 

Jury attitudes in Tampa Bay personal injury cases continue to vary by venue. While serious accident and injury claims involving unsafe conduct still result in significant verdicts, jurors are more cautious with claims lacking strong diagnostic support. Clear records, credible experts, and fact-based pleadings matter more than ever.
 

Technology and litigation funding are extending some cases, while others resolve faster due to early data-driven evaluations.

Speeding, distracted driving, and impaired driving remain leading causes of serious crashes on Tampa Bay roadways. Clear safety policies, real-time driving feedback, and regular coaching reduce crashes — and help protect both drivers and the public.
 

Strong injury cases are built on early evidence preservation, clear medical support, and experienced legal guidance. Whether you are an injured person seeking compensation or a business managing risk, preparation and transparency are essential in today’s Tampa Bay personal injury landscape.

For questions or concerns about Florida personal injury, auto accidents or any other legal issues, we offer a free consultation and detailed case evaluation.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/tampa-personal-injury-lawyers/

ACCIDENT AND INJURY CLAIMS EVOLVE IN TAMPA – 1/8/26

The post ACCIDENT AND INJURY CLAIMS ARE EVOLVING IN TAMPA appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
51% AT FAULT = $0 IN TAMPA ACCIDENTS https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/11/20/51-at-fault/ Thu, 20 Nov 2025 17:51:51 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34695 51% at fault = $0 in Tampa accidents. Are you protected?

The post 51% AT FAULT = $0 IN TAMPA ACCIDENTS appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
51% at Fault = $0 in tampa accidents

Tampa Injury Claims: 51% at fault = $0 in auto accidents, victims only have 2 Years to Act
 

Florida injury law has changed in recent years and if you don’t know the new rules, you could lose your case before it ever gets off the ground.

Under HB 837, Florida follows a modified comparative negligence system.

Key changes that affect every Florida driver:

   

•    If you’re found more than 50% at fault, or 51% at fault or over, you recover nothing.

•    If you’re 50% or less at fault, you can still recover—but your award will be reduced by your percentage of fault.

On top of that, the statute of limitations for negligence cases has been slashed from 4 years to just 2 years. Miss that window, and your claim is gone.

Tampa juries are already showing how powerful these changes are. In recent Hillsborough County trials, defendants admitted fault, but the jury still gave zero to the injured party because causation or fault percentage tipped the wrong way.

Quick Self-Check: Are you on track?
 

✅ Did you seek medical care right away?
✅ Are you keeping all treatment records & bills?
✅ Have you avoided giving a “fault-admitting” statement?
✅ Is evidence (photos, videos, witness contacts) preserved?
✅ Have you marked your 2-year deadline on the calendar?

For businesses and property owners, HB 837 also tilted the rules. Slip-and-fall and negligent security claims now face tighter requirements. Injured parties need stronger evidence up front—and juries are holding them to it.

Our car accident lawyers are very experienced and fully prepared to litigate aggressively on behalf of our clients. There are no up front fees or costs unless we win and our consultations are always free. Reach us by phone, email, or our quick contact form. And if you’re still unsure, have a look at the reviews we receive.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/personal-injury/resources/legal-impacts-of-aggressive-driving/

NEWSLETTER: 51% at fault = $0 in tampa accidents – are you protected? – 11/20/25

The post 51% AT FAULT = $0 IN TAMPA ACCIDENTS appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
AGGRESSIVE DRIVING IN PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUITS https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/10/23/aggressive-driving/ Thu, 23 Oct 2025 16:57:03 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34682 Legal Impacts of Aggressive Driving in Personal Injury Lawsuits

The post AGGRESSIVE DRIVING IN PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUITS appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
LEGAL IMPACTS OF AGGRESSIVE DRIVING IN PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUITS

The New Face of Road Rage in Tampa Bay – 14 Aggressive Driving Behaviors, Legal Impacts & Local Insights
 

As more vehicles crowd Tampa Bay’s roads, the chances of aggressive driving and “road rage” incidents are rising. In Hillsborough County alone, in 2024 there were 26,260 traffic crashes, resulting in 17,354 reported injuries and 181 fatalities.
In 2022, the crash rate per 100,000 in Hillsborough was 1,857.7 — higher than Florida’s state average of 1,780.7.
When aggressive behavior contributes to a crash, it can shift not just legal strategy — it can change the outcome of a personal injury claim. This guide demonstrates how.

Section I: Fourteen Aggressive DRIVING Behaviors to Watch
 

Below is a local-tailored list of common road rage / aggressive driving behaviors (with examples you may see in Tampa traffic). Not all are “road rage” in a legal sense, but all carry risk.
  1. Tailgating / following too closely — common on I-275, I-4, Selmon; leaves little margin for error.
  2. Brake-checking — driver suddenly slams brakes to provoke or intimidate the following vehicle.
  3. Cutting off / forcing a merge — refusing to let someone into your lane, or sudden swerves.
  4. Frequent honking / aggressive horn blasts (not just a polite beep).
  5. Flashing headlights repeatedly (especially high-to-low, or in quick bursts).
  6. Verbal insults / obscene gestures — even without contact, the threat can escalate.
  7. Pursuit / tail-chasing — following someone aggressively after an incident or perceived insult.
  8. Forcing another vehicle off the road / toward curb or shoulder.
  9. Squeezing through narrow gaps (“squeezer maneuvers”) in traffic jams.
  10. Aggressive cut-ins near exits or ramps — especially on I-75 / U.S. 41, close to Brandon or Tampa outskirts.
  11. Illegal shoulder use / passing on the shoulder.
  12. Intentional side-swipe or minor bump contact (touching bumpers deliberately).
  13. Exiting your car to confront another driver (physically or verbally).
  14. Using your vehicle as a weapon (ramming, blocking paths).
Some of these are more borderline “reckless driving” than full-blown road rage, but all can escalate quickly.

Section II: Why AGGRESSIVE DRIVING Behaviors Matter — Crash Risk & Escalation
 

  • Reduced reaction window: behaviors like tailgating and cut-ins leave almost zero room to respond.
  • Provocation spiral: a perceived slight (cut-off, honk, gesture) can trigger retaliation — e.g. chasing, brake-checking, blocking.
  • Collateral danger: in dense Tampa corridors, aggressive driving moves often impact other innocent motorists or bystanders.
  • Evidence magnet: many of these behaviors leave “traces” — skid marks, dashcam video, witness accounts — which can be pivotal in a legal case.
  • Statistical context: from 2018–2020, Hillsborough County logged ~82,359 crashes. Among contributing factors listed: tailgating, reckless/road rage driving, improper lane changes.

Section III: How Road Rage Behavior Affects Personal Injury Claims
 

This is where experienced personal injury lawyers can really help improve the outcome of a car accident claim – by connecting aggressive driving to settlement dynamics and legal strategy.

A. When Defendant’s Aggression Helps You
    

  1. Stronger narrative:  You’re not just an unlucky victim — you were targeted (or at least endangered) by hostile conduct. This reframes the case from “accident” to “dangerous driving.”
  2. Enhanced non-economic damages:  Courts and insurers are more likely to consider increased pain & suffering, emotional distress, and fear of recurrence when the defendant’s conduct shows willfulness or aggression.
  3. Potential for punitive damages:  In Florida, punitive damages may be awarded in extreme cases when the defendant’s conduct rises to gross negligence or intentional misconduct.
    ◦    Statutory requirement: the plaintiff must make a “reasonable showing” in the record to support a punitive claim. FindLaw Codes+1
    ◦    Caps: generally limited to 3× compensatory damages or $500,000, whichever is greater.
    ◦    Exceptions: if the defendant acted with “specific intent to harm,” there is no cap. Or, if the conduct was motivated purely by unreasonable financial gain, the cap may increase to 4× compensatory damages or $2 million. 
    ◦    Courts scrutinize punitive claims heavily: clear and convincing evidence is required.
  4. Leverage in settlement:  Even if punitive damages don’t ultimately succeed, the threat of a punitive claim can push insurers to make more generous offers rather than risk a trial.

B. When Your Own AGGRESSIVE DRIVING Behavior Hurts You
 

  1. Comparative negligence:  Florida applies comparative fault: if you are partly responsible (e.g. for tailgating, aggressive gestures), your recovery may be reduced proportionally.
  2. Provocation defense:  If the defendant claims you provoked them, they may argue your conduct triggered their response or that they acted in perceived self-defense.
  3. Damage to credibility / sympathy:  Aggressive behavior by you (yelling, honking, exiting car) can harm how jurors or adjusters perceive your claim.
To learn more about the impacts of aggressive driving in personal injury lawsuits – including examples of case scenarios, what to do if you’re in an accident involving road rage, some key data, statistics, and road rage hotspots in the Tampa Bay Area of Hillsborough County, see:
Our car accident lawyers are very experienced and fully prepared to litigate aggressively on behalf of our clients. There are no up front fees or costs unless we win and our consultations are always free. Reach us by phone, email, or our quick contact form. And if you’re still unsure, have a look at the reviews we receive.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/personal-injury/resources/legal-impacts-of-aggressive-driving/

NEWSLETTER: LEGAL IMPACTS OF AGGRESSIVE DRIVING IN PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUITS – 10/23/25

The post AGGRESSIVE DRIVING IN PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUITS appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
IS $10,000 PIP PROTECTION ENOUGH? WHAT HAPPENS AFTER A SERIOUS AUTO ACCIDENT IN FLORIDA? https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/09/25/is-10000-pip-protection-enough/ Thu, 25 Sep 2025 17:47:43 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34654 Is $10,000 PIP Protection Enough? What Happens After a Serious Auto Accident in Florida?

The post IS $10,000 PIP PROTECTION ENOUGH? WHAT HAPPENS AFTER A SERIOUS AUTO ACCIDENT IN FLORIDA? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
IS $10,000 PIP PROTECTION ENOUGH?  WHAT HAPPENS AFTER A SERIOUS AUTO ACCIDENT IN FLORIDA?

If you’re injured in a car accident in Florida, you might assume your auto insurance will cover your medical bills.

But many Floridians are surprised to learn that the standard Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage only provides $10,000 — and that money disappears fast if you’re facing hospital stays, surgeries, or rehabilitation.

So what happens if your medical bills reach $50,000 or more, and your policy caps at $10,000?  Several factors come into play and there are a few potential options for recovery of medical costs.

How Florida’s No-Fault Insurance Works

 

When our law firm represents injured victims, we provide multiple car accident lawyers for each case.  This team of attorneys will work very aggressively to preserve every available right to full recovery and compensation.  Our goal is to achieve the best possible outcome on each case.

Recovering from injuries is difficult enough.  The right law firm can help make these situations much better for any victim.

Options When Medical Bills Exceed PIP PROTECTION LIMITS

If your medical expenses are much higher than your PIP limit, you may still have options:

  1. Health Insurance – If you have it, your health insurance may pick up some of the remaining costs.
  2. At-Fault Driver’s Insurance – If the other driver was negligent, your attorney can pursue their bodily injury liability coverage to cover additional damages.
  3. Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) Coverage This optional add-on to your own policy can be a lifeline if the at-fault driver has little or no insurance.
  4. Personal Lawsuit – If the at-fault driver has significant personal assets, your attorney may pursue them directly.

Can You Get a Higher Coverage Limit?

Yes — but only before an accident happens.

  • Many insurance companies offer Medical Payments (“MedPay”) coverage, which stacks on top of your PIP protection and can raise your available coverage to $20,000, $50,000, or more.
  • Adding UM/UIM coverage is also critical. Florida doesn’t require it, but it protects you when the other driver’s policy won’t cover your damages.
Why Legal Guidance Matters

Insurance companies don’t make this process easy. They may delay, deny, or minimize claims — especially when injuries are severe. As experienced Tampa personal injury lawyers, Fernandez Law Group has a strong history of:

  • Identifying every available source of compensation.
  • Pushing back against lowball settlement offers.
  • Ensuring medical providers and insurers follow the law.
  • Helping our clients recover the full value of their damages, not just what’s left after PIP protection runs out.

That $10,000 PIP protection limit can be very limiting.  If your injuries are serious, your recovery often depends on pursuing additional claims and coverages.  The sooner you get an attorney involved, the more options you’ll have to protect your health and financial future.

Our car accident lawyers are very experienced and fully prepared to litigate aggressively on behalf of our clients. There are no up front fees or costs unless we win and our consultations are always free. Reach us by phone, email, or our quick contact form. And if you’re still unsure, have a look at the reviews we receive.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/personal-injury/tampa-truck-accident-lawyers/

NEWSLETTER: Is $10,000 PIP Protection Enough? What Happens After a Serious Auto Accident in Florida? – 9/25/25

The post IS $10,000 PIP PROTECTION ENOUGH? WHAT HAPPENS AFTER A SERIOUS AUTO ACCIDENT IN FLORIDA? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
TRUCKING ACCIDENTS IN FLORIDA – WHO IS REALLY LIABLE? https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/09/11/trucking-accidents-in-florida/ Thu, 11 Sep 2025 16:35:29 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34650 Tampa E-Bike Injuries are Surging - Who is Liable?

The post TRUCKING ACCIDENTS IN FLORIDA – WHO IS REALLY LIABLE? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
TRUCKING ACCIDENTS IN FLORIDA – WHO IS REALLY LIABLE?
Trucking accidents on Florida’s busy highways like I-4, I-75, and I-275 can cause devastating injuries. Unlike a standard car crash, determining who’s legally responsible in a commercial truck accident is rarely straightforward. 
Multiple parties may share liability, which makes working with an experienced personal injury attorney critical.

Who Can Be Held Liable After a Trucking Accident?

1. The Truck Driver

If the driver was distracted, impaired, fatigued, or simply negligent, they can be held personally responsible for injuries and damages. Florida law requires commercial drivers to meet higher safety standards because of the risks posed by large trucks.
2. The Trucking Company
 
Even if the driver is primarily at fault, the company employing them can also be liable under several legal theories:
  • Vicarious Liability – Employers are often responsible for the actions of employees who are driving on the job.
  • Negligent Hiring or Training – If a trucking company hired a driver without a valid CDL (Commercial Driver’s License), or failed to conduct proper background checks and training, they can be held directly accountable.
  • Pressure to Violate Safety Rules – Some companies push drivers to meet unrealistic delivery schedules, leading to hours-of-service violations and unsafe driving.

3. Other Potential Parties
 

  • Maintenance Contractors – If poor truck maintenance led to brake or tire failure.
  • Loading Companies – If improperly loaded cargo caused the accident.
  • Manufacturers – If a defective truck part contributed to the crash.

What If the Driver Wasn’t Licensed?
 

Operating a commercial truck without the proper CDL is a serious violation. If a crash occurs and the driver lacked proper licensing—or the company knowingly allowed it—the trucking company can face severe liability. Courts and insurance carriers typically view this as negligence per se, which strengthens the victim’s claim.

Why You Need a Personal Injury Lawyer
 

Because multiple parties may share responsibility, identifying all potential sources of compensation is key to ensuring a fair recovery. A skilled personal injury lawyer can:
  • Investigate the driver’s qualifications, training, and driving history.
  • Review the trucking company’s hiring practices and safety policies.
  • Examine electronic logging devices (ELDs), black box data, and maintenance records.
  • Pursue claims against every liable party—driver, company, contractors, or manufacturers.
  • Negotiate with powerful insurance companies who often try to shift blame or minimize payouts.
Trucking accidents in Florida require more than just a standard insurance claim—they demand a thorough investigation into all potential sources of liability. Whether it’s the driver, the trucking company, or other third parties, working with an experienced personal injury lawyer helps injured victims secure the maximum settlement available.
Our personal injury lawyers are very experienced with trucking accidents and are fully prepared to litigate aggressively on behalf of our clients. There are no up front fees or costs unless we win and our consultations are always free. Reach us by phone, email, or our quick contact form. And if you’re still unsure, have a look at the reviews we receive.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More: https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/personal-injury/tampa-truck-accident-lawyers/

NEWSLETTER: TRUCKING ACCIDENTS IN FLORIDA – WHO IS REALLY LIABLE? – 9/11/25

The post TRUCKING ACCIDENTS IN FLORIDA – WHO IS REALLY LIABLE? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
TAMPA E-BIKE INJURIES ARE SURGING – WHO IS LIABLE? https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/08/28/tampa-e-bike-injuries/ Thu, 28 Aug 2025 16:19:50 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34643 Tampa E-Bike Injuries are Surging - Who is Liable?

The post TAMPA E-BIKE INJURIES ARE SURGING – WHO IS LIABLE? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
TAMPA E-BIKE INJURIES ARE SURGING – WHO IS LIABLE?

E-Bikes & E-Scooters Are Sending Tampa Teens and Adults to the ER—Who Pays the Bill?

Emergency rooms in Tampa are seeing a sharp rise in serious e-scooter and e-bike injuries. Doctors are warning about head trauma, fractures, paralysis, and in some cases, fatalities. The issue has become a growing concern for parents, riders, and anyone sharing the road.
 But when the unthinkable happens, the question quickly shifts from safety to liability: who pays?

Here’s the breakdown under Florida law:
 

  • PIP (Personal Injury Protection): Florida drivers may have PIP coverage, but it doesn’t always apply to non-vehicle riders like e-scooters.
  • MedPay & UM/UIM: Medical payments coverage and uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance can cover big gaps and are often the only safety net when the other driver has minimal insurance.
  • Homeowners/Renters Insurance: May cover accidents caused by, or involving minors, depending on the policy language.
  • Product & Maintenance Claims: If the e-bike or e-scooter failed due to a defect or poor maintenance, claims may extend to manufacturers or service providers.

And remember, under Florida’s 51% rule, if the rider is found more than 50% at fault for situations such as running a light, riding without a helmet and etc., recovery may not be possible.

Steps can be taken to help protect the rights of those injured in these types of accidents.

At the scene of a crash, capture these 10 things:
  • Photos of the accident site, vehicles/scooters, and road conditions
  • Photos of your injuries (immediate & visible)
  • Contact info for all drivers, riders, and witnesses
  • Insurance info from every involved driver
  • Screenshots of ride app trip data (e.g., Bird, Lime, Uber)
  • Helmet and equipment photos (condition at crash)
  • Police or incident report number
  • Emergency room/hospital intake paperwork
  • Short video statement (what happened, in your words)
  • Timestamped notes (pain, impact, events right after crash)

E-Bike Insurance Coverage FAQ


Q: Were you hit by a car?

➡ Yes → Driver’s auto liability may cover you.
➡ Your own PIP/MedPay may also apply.
Q: Was the other driver uninsured/underinsured?

➡ Yes → Your UM/UIM coverage can step in.
Q: Was it a solo crash (no car)?

➡ Check homeowners/renters insurance for liability coverage.
➡ If a mechanical failure: explore product liability claim.
Q: Was a commercial scooter involved (Bird, Lime, etc.)?

➡ Preserve app data and report incident through the app.
➡ Some companies carry limited liability coverage.
Q: Is fault disputed?

➡ Remember: if you’re found >50% at fault, you may recover nothing under Florida law.
When e-bike injuries occur, we’ll be ready.  Our accident lawyers are very experienced and fully prepared to litigate aggressively on behalf of our clients.
We’ve been successfully representing clients who were victims in motorcycle accidents and bicycle accidents for years.  E-bike injuries and accidents are very similar in nature.  Our experience in litigating those types of cases gives us an advantage when we handle e-bike injuries and cases.
There are no up front fees or costs unless we win and our consultations are always free. Reach us by phone, email, or our quick contact form. And if you’re still unsure, have a look at the reviews we receive.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about any of the new Florida Laws in 2025, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.  

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.  

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More:  https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/criminal-defense-lawyers/

NEWSLETTER: TAMPA E-BIKE INJURIES ARE SURGING – WHO IS LIABLE? – 8/28/25

The post TAMPA E-BIKE INJURIES ARE SURGING – WHO IS LIABLE? appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
STAND YOUR GROUND DEFENSE DENIED IN HOWARD FRANKLAND STABBING https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/2025/05/22/stand-your-ground-defense/ Thu, 22 May 2025 13:07:05 +0000 https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/?p=34574 Lucy's Law to enhance boating safety is passed by Florida legislature. In a significant move to improve boating safety, the Florida Legislature has passed "Lucy's Law," a bill named in honor of 17-year-old Luciana "Lucy" Fernandez, who tragically lost her life in a boating accident in 2022.

The post STAND YOUR GROUND DEFENSE DENIED IN HOWARD FRANKLAND STABBING appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>
STAND YOUR GROUND DEFENSE DENIED IN HOWARD FRANKLAND STABBING

In a significant legal decision, a Florida judge has denied former Assistant U.S. Attorney Matthew Scruggs’ attempt to invoke the state’s “Stand Your Ground” law in his defense against charges stemming from a stabbing incident on the Howard Frankland Bridge.

The incident occurred when Scruggs’ vehicle was struck by another driver, leading to a confrontation during which Scruggs allegedly stabbed the other driver multiple times. Scruggs claimed self-defense under the “Stand Your Ground” statute, asserting that he perceived an imminent threat to his safety.

However, the court found that the circumstances did not meet the legal criteria for such a defense. The judge determined that Scruggs’ actions were not justified under the law, as there was insufficient evidence to support a reasonable belief of imminent danger that would warrant the use of deadly force without the duty to retreat.

Scruggs testified that he smashed the man’s window and stabbed him about seven times in the arm because he feared for his safety.  After hearing from Scruggs, the victim and several witnesses, Judge Meyer determined that Scruggs was “acting out of anger and frustration, not in fear” and set a trial for Sept. 9. 

Scruggs’ lawyers had sought to dismiss the case under Florida’s controversial stand your ground law, which extended self-defense in Florida by removing what’s known as the “duty to retreat” when a person is faced with the threat of a violent confrontation.

This ruling means that Scruggs will face trial without the protections afforded by the “Stand Your Ground” law, proceeding under standard legal procedures for the charges against him.

The case has garnered attention due to Scruggs’ former role as a federal prosecutor and the broader implications for the application of self-defense laws in Florida.

The denial of the “Stand Your Ground” defense in this case underscores the judiciary’s careful scrutiny of such claims, particularly when the use of deadly force is involved. It also highlights the ongoing debates surrounding self-defense statutes and their interpretations within the legal system.

If you have questions or concerns about the Stand Your Ground Defense laws in Florida, reach out to us anytime for a free consultation and detailed case review.

EXPERIENCE.  STANDARDS.  RESULTS.

With a combined legal experience of over 50 years in both State and Federal courts, the Tampa Lawyers at Fernandez Law Group are committed to providing quality service to clients while maintaining a high level of respect, integrity, and appreciation for each individuals’ legal needs.  If you have questions about Lucy’s Law and how it affects your rights, we’re here to help.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers work aggressively seeking compensation for damages and have recovered millions of dollars in settlements.

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers fight to protect the rights of our clients and have successfully litigated to reduce thousands of sentences and fines.

We offer free initial consultations with detailed case reviews.


CALL US TODAY AT 813-489-3222, USE OUR CONTACT FORM, EMAIL OR TEXT US FOR A FREE CONSULTATION AND CASE EVALUATION.

Learn More:  https://thefernandezlawgroup.com/criminal-defense-lawyers/

NEWSLETTER: STAND YOUR GROUND DEFENSE DENIED IN HOWARD FRANKLAND STABBING – 5/22/25

The post STAND YOUR GROUND DEFENSE DENIED IN HOWARD FRANKLAND STABBING appeared first on The Fernandez Law Group.

]]>